Notes from the Left Coast

Drummond Pike’s Blog

How do you sign up to do torture? Where is that dotted line filled out saying that, “no, I don’t mind seeing another human being scream in agony, agony that I cause in the name of something or in the interest of ‘intelligence’?” The answer, according to Stanford’s Phillip Zimbardo, one of our nation’s experts on the subject, is that people don’t sign up. They absorb the permission from the system they are a part of.

At the recent TED Conference in Monterey, Zimbardo set forth his trim assessment that there are essentially no “bad apples”, which is how the military explained Abu Ghraib. In fact, he asserted, there aren’t even bad barrels. Instead, there are bad barrel makers – the designers of the system – that really hold responsibility. If you need any reinforcement for this argument, just read JoAnne Wypijewski’s extraordinary article in the March/April issue of Mother Jones. It will curl your hair. They have created a system that will not learn from its experience and will not accept responsibility for the wrong that was done. In so doing, they damage us all even more.

In her step by step excavation of the way the military has “held itself accountable”, she outlines in detail what we all know: the grunts on the ground paid a heavy price – many with years in prison. But NONE of their commanding officers has had anything more than a hand slap. It is truly remarkable, and, surprise, surprise, the press is oblivious. No coverage. No outrage. No accountability.

At one point, she recites what we may recall from early press reports – Secretary Rumsfeld received daily briefings on the intelligence gathered. He was focused on Abu Ghraib and had urged the use of the “strong” tactics used to achieve the intelligence as has often been reported. Everyone in the military knew that he and the Vice President believed in harsh tactics. That virtually all the intelligence was garbage seems beside the point. That no one holds any responsibility nor has been held accountable for one of the worst chapters in American history, and, arguably, one of the contributing factors to America’s precipitous decline in international circles.

Somehow, the defender of liberty and freedom and democracy has become the perpetrator of inhumanity, violence, and torture in the name of the emergency of terrorism. How was it that the Nazis explained why Jews needed to be rounded up? What emergency deprived them of their civil liberties?

Military necessity is used to justify the harshest measures of the state – the deprivation of a citizen’s rights. Has it ever been proven worthwhile? Outside of the mind-numbing, fiction of “24” on television, I don’t think so.